While Penske Racing didn't get a reversal of some of the severest penalties ever imposed by NASCAR it could claim a partial victory as Chief Appellate Officer John Middlebrook reduced seven team members' suspensions from six to two (points) races.
In his official ruling, Middlebrook said “After looking at all the facts and data and interpretations from the rule book, I have decided to uphold the original fines and points penalties,” said John Middlebrook, Chief Appellate Officer.
|
Photo: NASCAR |
“However, I have decided to reduce the suspensions of the seven team members involved from six points races and the all-star race to two points races and the all-star race.”
Thus the remaining points penalties (25) against drivers, Brad Keselowski and Joey Logano, and $100,000 fines against their crew chiefs remain in force. Still replacing key crew members (crew chiefs, car chiefs and the competition director) is a serious penalty and they will miss this week's race at Darlington and the May 26th 600 miler at the team's home track the Charlotte Motor Speedway.
Suspension in NASCAR means not being able to be at the race track.
All-in-all Roger Penske was pleased with the decision. According to the 76-year old “the key thing” was getting his crewmen back to work.
"I think it was fair and equitable," Penske said. "After consideration by John Middlebrook, he felt the fines and penalties were overreaching and made the decision to reduce it.
"It was a good outcome for everyone. We're going to move on."
The penalties were issued after both Keselowski's and Logano's failed pre-race inspection in Texas for the mounting of the rear end suspension. During the appeal Penske said it was clear that his teams were working in "undefined" areas of the rulebook, and not necessarily "breaking" rules.”
The NASCAR appellate process, where suspensions were held in abeyance, also has allowed Penske Racing to start to put a strategy in place to provide interim crewman. Penske said the replacements would be named shortly.
Middlebrook, a retired General Motors Executive, has heard six appeals in his three-year tenure and has reduced penalties in five of those instances.